14 Easy to implement email marketing best practices to improve results

By Sean Tinney February 7, 2024

Sending emails can feel intimidating at first. It may even cause some “email anxiety” (yeah that’s a thing). But sending emails doesn’t have to be complicated or scary if you follow some basic email marketing best practices.

As you go through this list of best practices for email marketing, you won’t see guidelines about how many emails you should send, or how long your email needs to be, or the optimal length of a subject line. 

The truth is, that while these are all great and important questions, the answer to these questions is different for every company. You can only answer these with email testing (which by the way IS a best practice).

No matter what your business is or what industry you’re in, some tried-and-true best email marketing best practices can only help guide you to success. 

Email Marketing Best Practices

1 – Create emails that are easy to scan and read

Your subscriber’s inboxes are busy. To cut through the clutter and immediately catch and maintain your reader’s attention, your emails will need to be easy to read and scannable.

A scannable email allows your busy subscribers to get the important information they need much faster. So instead of opening an email, seeing an overwhelming block of text and sending your email to the trash folder, they’ll read and click.

There are a few tactics you can use to make your emails more scannable, like using descriptive and/or interesting headlines to quickly summarize your point. Or, catch your subscriber’s attention by writing short paragraphs and sentences. To further increase readability, you should use images and whitespace appropriately to separate chunks of text.

For the email below, Hotel Tonight uses three different sized headlines that vary from descriptive to interesting:

While the main header “Pics, Please” is intriguing and fun, the subheadlines below are descriptive. This combination grabs the attention of the reader and then quickly gives them context.

Additionally, by writing short sentences and separating paragraphs with images, they’re able to create an easy-to-read email.

2 – Make your emails accessible

Ensuring that your emails are accessible to all recipients, regardless of their abilities or disabilities, not only aligns with legal requirements but also reflects your commitment to reaching and engaging with a diverse audience.

By prioritizing email accessibility, you not only enhance the user experience for individuals with disabilities but also improve overall engagement and effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.

Here are some key strategies to make your emails more accessible:

Use simple fonts

The most accessible fonts are Tahoma, Calibri, Helvetica, Arial, Verdana, and Times New Roman. Learn more about the most accessible fonts.

Align your copy to the left

Rather than the center or right. Screen readers are better at reading left-aligned text in a comprehensible way.

Create clear spacing

Create clear spacing around your lines, letters, and paragraphs. For example, your line height should be 1.5 times the font size.

Add a clear alt text description

Even if your images and GIFs don’t contain textual content, it’s crucial to include descriptive alternative text (ALT text) that clearly conveys the subject or context of the visual content. This enables assistive technologies to provide accurate descriptions for individuals who rely on them.

3 – Create automated email campaigns

Email automation allows you to send the right message to the right people at the right time without having to set up and send one-off emails every time.

A perfect example of an automated email marketing campaign is your welcome email. Studies have shown a welcome email can generate 320% more revenue per email, 4 times higher open rates than other emails, and 5 times higher click-through rates than promotional emails. 

In addition to the welcome series, you can set up email automation campaigns for:

• Cart abandonments
• Thank you for your purchase or download or sign up
• Confirmation of an opt-in
• An event based trigger like an anniversary or birthday
• If a customer hasn’t opened an email in several months, you can trigger a “We miss you” message

While automated email campaigns can save you time and lead to higher results, it’s important not to set it and forget it. You should still monitor the performance of your automated email series and find ways to test so you can improve your email performance.

4 – Segment your email list

Email segmentation is a way to break up your list into smaller, more targeted groups, based on a specific set of criteria. 

When you segment, you can send more personalized and relevant content or offers to customers based on similar interests, geographic location, purchase history, and so much more.

Plus, it leads to a higher open rate, click rate, and conversation rate. And more importantly, higher revenue. Some marketers reported as much as 760% increase in revenue.

RELATED: 20+ Ways to segment your emails to boost your marketing efforts

5 – Personalize your emails

Which of the two following examples do you think would trigger more foot traffic?

In this example, if I know Diane’s location preference is in Springfield and she’s previously purchased Martha Stewart products and LEGO’s, then this personalized email will resonate much more than the more generic example.

Email personalization allows you to create more targeted emails that stand out in the inbox. You should be personalizing everything in your emails from the subject line to the actual email content to the offer itself.

6 – Create engaging email content

The purpose of your emails is to get people to read them so they can take the desired action. So obviously you want to create an email that is compelling and engaging. For some people that’s easier said than done. If you’re like me, then writing doesn’t come naturally, but don’t worry. AWeber has resources to help you write amazing emails.

7 – Have a call to action

Most emails need to have a call to action. Think of the result or action you want your subscriber to achieve, now call it out. Sure you will occasionally send an email that doesn’t require a call to action (or CTA), like a thank you email, and that’s fine.

For those other emails you need to have some form of a call to action. This could be a CTA button or hyperlink which directs subscribers to your website to read a blog, sign up for an event, or make a purchase. Other types of call to actions could have the results of driving traffic into a physical location.

Plus, you can get creative with your CTAs. Don’t feel like you can only use “click here,” “read more,” or “shop now.” Check out how shoe store DSW phrased its call to action in an email promoting a “buy one get one” offer:

8 – Use confirmed opt-in

Setting up a signup form on your landing page or Facebook page is a great way to grow your email list. But once they sign up, send an email to confirm their email address. 

Getting a subscriber to verify again that they want to receive your email is a great way to improve your delivery rate. And since they confirmed their email address, you know they really wanted to sign up. This should make them more responsive and lead to higher email engagement.

9 – Do not purchase an email list

If we had a megaphone for this point, we would use it. Never purchase an email list. Sending emails which people didn’t provide their permission for is considered spam — not to mention illegal.

When you use a purchased email list, you’re setting yourself up for disaster. Since these people didn’t opt-in to hear from you, they begin to mark your messages as spam. This will lead to lower delivery rates and your emails will start to go straight to spam folders where they will never get seen or open.

AWeber, among other reputable email marketing service companies, will not allow you to import a purchased list. 

10 – Clean your email list

Cleaning your email list should be viewed as addition by subtraction. By removing contacts from your list who have not opened your email over a specific period of time, you will receive better open rates. How? Because you’re only sending to those subscribers who are really interested in your product or service.

You also reduce the risk that an inactive subscriber will mark your email as spam, which could negatively impact your delivery rate.

It is recommended that your email list should be cleaned at least once every six months. 

11 – Do not use a no-reply email address

Have you ever received an email from a noreply email address? It looks something like this – noreply@domain.com.

You should never be sending an email with a noreply address. And the reasons are obvious:

• A noreply email address decreases deliverability
• It increases your chances of being labeled as spam
• By not allowing your customers to reply to your email you are creating a poor customer experience

Instead of having a reply email address as noreply@domain.com, have it come from an actual person or customerservice@domain.com. Either way, to ensure your customers questions are answered in a timely manner, make sure you have someone actively managing this email address.

12 – Test emails before sending

Proof-reading your email is a critical step before pressing “send.”

Part of this process should be sending yourself a test email before scheduling your email. I recommend setting up a pre-flight checklist, where you can check all elements of your email to make sure it’s in good shape to send.

Send yourself a test email and check for these important email marketing elements:

• Email is rendering properly
• Images are loading
• You have alt text for your images (for images that don’t render this will tell the reader what the image is about)
• There are no spelling mistakes
• Your hyperlinks and call to action buttons take you to a live page
• It looks good on both  laptop and mobile

13 – Analyze your email marketing stats

But how do you know your emails are working? By looking at the data. One of the most important email marketing campaign best practices is to understand how your emails are performing. 

The most important email marketing performance data you should look at are:

Open Rate

Click Rate

Delivery Rate

Opt Out Rate

14 – A/B split test your email campaigns

Anyone can create a marketing email that gets opened and clicked. But if you want to create a truly remarkable email experience for your customers, you need to split test.

I hear all too often, what should I test? Well, with an email service provider like AWeber, you can and should test everything. 

Here are a few email test ideas to get those creative juices flowing:

• Different subject line messages
• Image vs no image in the email
• Different color call to action button
• Time of day
• Short subject line vs long subject line
• Short email message vs long email message
• Who the email is from – a person’s name, customer service, the name of your company

Testing will ultimately help you understand your customer better, which will lead to a better experience.

Remember, once your test is done, analyze your stats. 

Email marketing is not rocket science. And once you start following these email marketing best practices, I’m sure you’ll see even more success growing your business — and have some fun in the process as well. 

Take Your Email Skills to the Next Level

Now that you know the most important email marketing best practices it’s time to get all the tools and resources you need to become an email marketing pro in no time.

I get it, running a business is like working two full-time jobs. Sometimes it may be a challenge to dedicate the time and energy into marketing your business. We’ve made it a little easier for you with this guide: “How to grow your business with email marketing”.  

Download it today.